Exercise Comparison
Cable Shrugs vs Scapular Pull-Up




Side-by-Side
Muscle Analysis
Shared
Only in Scapular Pull-Up
Instructions
Cable Shrugs
Grasp a cable bar attachment that is attached to a low pulley with a shoulder width or slightly wider overhand (palms facing down) grip.
Stand erect close to the pulley with your arms extended in front of you holding the bar. This will be your starting position.
Lift the bar by elevating the shoulders as high as possible as you exhale. Hold the contraction at the top for a second. Tip: The arms should remain extended at all times. Refrain from using the biceps to help lift the bar. Only the shoulders should be moving up and down.
Lower the bar back to the original position.
Repeat for the recommended amount of repetitions.
Scapular Pull-Up
Take a pronated grip on a pull-up bar.
From a hanging position, raise yourself a few inches without using your arms. Do this by depressing your shoulder girdle in a reverse shrugging motion.
Pause at the completion of the movement, and then slowly return to the starting position before performing more repetitions.
Verdict
Both exercises target the traps. Cable Shrugs is a beginner exercise using cable, while Scapular Pull-Up is beginner and uses none. Choose Cable Shrugs if you have access to cable, or Scapular Pull-Up if you prefer none.