Pinpoint
Exercises/Compare

Exercise Comparison

Barbell Shrug vs Scapular Pull-Up

Barbell Shrug - starting position
Barbell Shrug - ending position
Barbell Shrug
beginner·Barbell·isolation
Scapular Pull-Up - starting position
Scapular Pull-Up - ending position
Scapular Pull-Up
beginner·None·isolation

Side-by-Side

Barbell Shrug
VS
Scapular Pull-Up
beginner
Level
beginner
Barbell
Equipment
None
isolation
Mechanic
isolation
pull
Force
pull
Strength
Category
Strength
traps
Primary
traps
None
Secondary
latsmiddle back

Muscle Analysis

Shared

traps

Only in Scapular Pull-Up

latsmiddle back

Instructions

Barbell Shrug

1

Stand up straight with your feet at shoulder width as you hold a barbell with both hands in front of you using a pronated grip (palms facing the thighs). Tip: Your hands should be a little wider than shoulder width apart. You can use wrist wraps for this exercise for a better grip. This will be your starting position.

2

Raise your shoulders up as far as you can go as you breathe out and hold the contraction for a second. Tip: Refrain from trying to lift the barbell by using your biceps.

3

Slowly return to the starting position as you breathe in.

4

Repeat for the recommended amount of repetitions.

Scapular Pull-Up

1

Take a pronated grip on a pull-up bar.

2

From a hanging position, raise yourself a few inches without using your arms. Do this by depressing your shoulder girdle in a reverse shrugging motion.

3

Pause at the completion of the movement, and then slowly return to the starting position before performing more repetitions.

Verdict

Both exercises target the traps. Barbell Shrug is a beginner exercise using barbell, while Scapular Pull-Up is beginner and uses none. Choose Barbell Shrug if you have access to barbell, or Scapular Pull-Up if you prefer none.

Pinpoint·Interactive 3D Anatomy & Exercise Guide